False Positives in the Identification of Dynamic Earthquake Triggering

Jeanne L. Hardebeck, Nicolas DeSalvio, Wenyuan Fan, & Andrew J. Barbour

Submitted September 7, 2025, SCEC Contribution #14511, 2025 SCEC Annual Meeting Poster #TBD

Dynamic earthquake triggering is commonly identified through the temporal correlation between increased seismicity rates and global earthquakes that are possible triggering events. However, correlation does not imply causation. False positives may occur when unrelated seismicity rate changes coincidently occur at around the time of candidate triggers. We investigate the expected false positive rate in Southern California with global M≥6 earthquakes as candidate triggers. We compute the false positive rate by applying the statistical tests used by DeSalvio and Fan (2023) to synthetic earthquake catalogs with no real dynamic triggering. We find a false positive rate of ~3.5-8.5% when realistic earthquake clustering is present, consistent with the 95% confidence typically used in seismology. However, when this false positive rate is applied to the tens of thousands of spatial-temporal windows in Southern California tested in DeSalvio and Fan (2023), thousands of false positives are expected. The expected false positive occurrence is large enough to explain the observed apparent triggering following 70% of large global earthquakes (DeSalvio & Fan, 2023), without requiring any true dynamic triggering. Aside from the known triggering from the nearby El Mayor-Cucapah, Mexico, earthquake, the spatial and temporal characteristics of the reported triggering are indistinguishable from random false positives. This implies that best practice for dynamic triggering studies that depend on temporal correlation is to estimate the false positive rate and investigate whether the observed apparent triggering is distinguishable from the correlations that may occur by chance.

Key Words
dynamic earthquake triggering, false positives

Citation
Hardebeck, J. L., DeSalvio, N., Fan, W., & Barbour, A. J. (2025, 09). False Positives in the Identification of Dynamic Earthquake Triggering. Poster Presentation at 2025 SCEC Annual Meeting.

Related Projects & Working Groups
Seismology